Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Roger McGuinn, Peace on You (1974)




It’s awkward and unpleasant to see McGuinn so exposed here, without the rotating cast of talented Byrds to hide behind. Left to his own devices, he reveals himself an uninspired interpreter of other people’s songs (and a godawful  selector on that front—when the dude’s not doing Dylan, he seems to think Dan Fogelberg is the next best thing), and an untalented songwriter with nothing to say and no stylistic flourishes to conceal the absence. It’s really a sad, dispiriting listen in every way, checked-out and half-assed and impossible to commit to memory, possibly the most lifeless thing McGuinn ever did. When that cover art is the best thing about the LP, you know you're in for suffering. 

No comments:

Post a Comment